quant small and bhandhan small cap? why reason?
After analyzing the holdings in the two Small Cap mutual fund portfolios you uploaded:
1. Quant Small Cap Fund
-
Top Holdings:
-
Reliance Industries – 10.48%
-
Jio Financial – 5.23%
-
Aegis Logistics – 3.95%
-
Aditya Birla Fashion – 3.24%
-
Poly Medicure – 3.09%
-
Bikaji Foods – 3.01%
-
-
Characteristics:
-
Heavy allocation to top few stocks, especially Reliance Industries and Jio Financial (together ~15%+).
-
Exposure to energy, logistics, fashion retail, healthcare, and FMCG.
-
Some large-cap names (Reliance, Jio) exist despite being a small-cap fund.
-
-
Investment Style: Aggressive, concentrated bets, some thematic focus, and not strictly small-cap exposure.
2. Bhansali Small Cap Fund
-
Top Holdings:
-
Sobha Ltd – 3.13%
-
LT Foods – 2.38%
-
South Indian Bank – 2.39%
-
Chela Finance – 2.19%
-
PCBL Chemical – 1.89%
-
Arvind Ltd – 1.83%
-
-
Characteristics:
-
Broader distribution across many companies.
-
Sectors include construction, consumer staples, financials, textiles, and chemicals.
-
Total holdings: 185 companies, indicating high diversification.
-
Most holdings are true small-cap or micro-cap businesses.
-
-
Investment Style: Conservative within small-cap space with wide diversification to reduce volatility and risk.
🔍 Which Small Cap Fund Has Higher Risk and Potential for High Gains?
✅ Winner: Quant Small Cap Fund
🔼 Reasons (Pros):
-
High-conviction bets in top performers (e.g., Reliance, Jio).
-
Aggressive sector rotation and alpha-chasing strategy.
-
Tactical exposure to strong mid-to-large cap performers even in a small-cap fund, to boost returns.
-
Historically known for delivering outperformance in bull runs.
🔽 Cons:
-
Very high risk due to concentration.
-
Volatile during market corrections (less cushion from diversification).
-
May deviate from small-cap theme, making it unsuitable for strict small-cap exposure seekers.
-
Exposure to cyclicals and high beta sectors (energy, fashion, logistics).
🟢 Bhansali Small Cap Fund: Lower Risk, Stable Gains
✅ Pros:
-
Broad sector allocation.
-
True small-cap focused.
-
Better risk-adjusted return profile for conservative investors.
-
Less likely to suffer extreme drawdowns due to diversification.
❌ Cons:
-
Gains may be slower and capped in bull markets.
-
Too diversified to generate alpha quickly.
-
May underperform aggressive funds during upcycles.
💡 Summary Recommendation:
| Goal | Recommended Fund | Why |
|---|---|---|
| High Risk, High Return | Quant Small Cap Fund | Concentrated, aggressive, fast-moving |
| Moderate Risk, Steady Return | Bhansali Small Cap Fund | Broad-based, diversified, small-cap purist |
Let me know if you want a side-by-side table with all holdings and sectors or a combined Excel-ready summary.